Those eyes say she's just as shocked as you are to discover the present like this...

Credit: TootyMcfruityPoots on Reddit

"Lillian’s demo-dog outfit for Stranger Thingsgiving and manger things viewing party"

Credit: oohsosleepy on Reddit

Credit: Impossible-Crew6529 on Reddit

After posting, the responses were perfect...

"Went for a walk in the park today, and these two little cuties followed me the whole time .So I brought them home with me"

Credit:  changle798 on Reddit

"These two were spotted in my neighborhood soaking in the sun on a garage roof"

Credit: NBAJam95 on Reddit

Credit: scootbert on Reddit

"I put a small bed at my door for street cats. It’s supposed to be for 2–3 cats. This is how it’s going:"

Credit: ALEXGP75O on Reddit

Don't let the cat out of the bag!

Credit: SaltyCatTreats on Reddit

"My wife has gone to visit her folks for New Years, this is how my cat sleeps with me when she's away...note his little arm on the pillow just like mine."

Credit: IKissedHerInnerThigh on Reddit

Credit: reganmcneal on Reddit

"I ain't kitten around"

Credit: Solid_State140 on Reddit

Credit: Ok_Squirrel_9367 on Reddit

Credit: Diligent_Pilot_1949 on Reddit

"She would be really good at playing hide and seek"

Credit: DS18299 on Reddit

Credit: @middlesis_tor on Instagram

"I know I am biased, but Mirin is the most adorable cat I have ever seen"

Credit: Koffievos on Reddit

"Three years in, they're finally starting to be friends. Warm fireplace helps bring them together though."

Credit: __slamallama__ on Reddit